August 4, 2025

In a groundbreaking report released this month, the American Medical Association (AMA) has cast a spotlight on the concerning lack of competition within the Pharmacy Benefit Manager (PBM) industry, a situation that may be driving up drug prices and limiting choices for consumers across the United States.
Pharmacy Benefit Managers are key players in the healthcare sector, acting as intermediaries between drug manufacturers and healthcare plans. They negotiate drug prices and manage pharmacy benefits, ostensibly to optimize healthcare outcomes and control costs. However, the AMA's recent findings suggest that the consolidation of power in this market may have the opposite effect, potentially harming both consumers and healthcare providers.
The report, which detailed the dominance of a few major players who control a significant portion of the market, raises alarms about the implications of such concentration. Industry giants are not only holding a tight rein over drug pricing but also the terms of service that affect where patients can fill their prescriptions and what medications are available to them.
This vertical integration, where large companies own or have significant stakes in various parts of the supply chain, is particularly troubling. It could limit competition even further, driving smaller players out of the market and reducing the incentive for cost reduction and service improvement.
The AMA's call to action is clear: there is a pressing need for regulatory oversight and potential reforms to ensure a competitive marketplace. Such measures would not only foster healthier competition but could also lead to more innovative solutions and better outcomes for patients.
Healthcare professionals, policy makers, and consumer rights groups are taking note of these findings, advocating for a thorough review and adjustment of antitrust laws as they apply to PBMs. The potential benefits of such changes include increased transparency, better access to necessary medications, and ultimately, lower costs for consumers.
As the debate unfolds, all eyes will be on the decisions of regulators and lawmakers, and whether they will take the necessary steps to unravel this complex knot and restore a competitive balance to the PBM market. The outcome could have significant ramifications not just for the healthcare industry, but for the welfare of millions of Americans reliant on prescription drugs for their health and well-being.