August 6, 2025


Delaware Moves to Cement Ban on Death Penalty in State Constitution

Delaware, once known for its high per capita execution rate, is on the verge of a groundbreaking legal reform. The state is progressing towards embedding a ban on the death penalty directly into its constitution. This step follows the abolition of capital punishment by the state supreme court in 2016 and its legislative repeal last year. If successful, Delaware will join Michigan and Puerto Rico in having a constitutional prohibition against capital punishment.

The Delaware legislature has already voted in favor of this constitutional amendment and will need to vote again in its next session to finalize the decision. This move underscores a deeper commitment to ensuring the permanency of the death penalty ban, safeguarding it against the whims of future legislative changes or shifts in judicial perspectives.

This initiative arises from an understanding of the transient nature of statutory bans and judicial rulings, which can be overturned with political shifts. History is replete with examples of states oscillating between abolishing and reinstating the death penalty, reflecting changing political climates rather than consistent judicial philosophy. Oregon and Arizona have seen the death penalty repealed and reinstated multiple times through referendums and legislative actions. Similarly, Nebraska abolished capital punishment in 2015, only for it to be reinstated by a voter referendum in 2016.

Delaware’s own fluctuating history with the death penalty underscores the necessity of a constitutional amendment. The state first abolished it in 1957, only to reinstate it four years later. The recent legislative efforts and the proposed constitutional amendment aim to prevent such reversals and embed the abolition into the state’s fundamental legal framework.

Constitutional amendments provide a more robust barrier against the reinstatement of capital punishment, as altering the constitution is significantly more challenging than passing legislation. This method also makes a profound moral and political statement, reflecting a collective and enduring commitment to human rights and the principles of justice.

In conclusion, Delaware's push to constitutionally ban the death penalty represents not just a legal safeguard but a moral stand, signaling an end to the state's complex and dark history with capital punishment. By moving the abolitionist efforts to the constitutional level, Delaware aims to ensure that there is no place for a punishment once deemed necessary but now recognized as inhumane and outdated.