September 8, 2025


Legal Ethics Roundup: A Month of Controversies from AI Mishaps to Judicial Misconduct

August was a whirlwind month in the world of legal ethics, with stories ranging from AI-generated legal documents causing uproar to ethical complaints against high-profile figures and judges.

Jack Smith's Legal Team Hits Back Against Ethics Complaint

In a significant development, lawyers for Jack Smith, the former special counsel known for his investigations into Donald J. Trump, have responded to an ethics complaint, calling it "imaginary and unfounded." The complaint, which has been a focal point of conservative criticism, pertains to Smith's role in criminal inquiries concerning Trump's handling of classified documents and attempts to overturn the 2020 election results.

Judge in LA Faces Discipline for In-Courtroom Threats

Meanwhile, in Los Angeles, Superior Court Judge Enrique Monguia has been publicly admonished after he threatened to shoot people in his courtroom. The judge's other remarks during sessions, which included derogatory comments about a woman and a juror, have also drawn severe criticism, reflecting poorly on courtroom decorum and judicial temperament.

Unprecedented Moves in Immigration Law and AI

In a controversial decision aimed at reducing a massive backlog of immigration cases, the DOJ has allowed attorneys without prior immigration case experience to serve as temporary judges. This move has sparked debate over the adequacy and fairness of such appointments.

In another tech-related debacle, OnlyFans' parent company has argued that legal briefs created using AI are flawed beyond repair, insisting that they be dismissed altogether. This incident highlights the growing pains associated with integrating AI into legal practices.

Elderly Judge’s Suspension Extended Amid Health Concerns

The judicial council has extended the suspension of 98-year-old U.S. Circuit Judge Pauline Newman for another year, citing non-compliance with an internal investigation into her fitness to serve. This decision has ignited discussions on age and capability in high-stakes judicial roles.

Ethical and Legal Battles Surge Across the Country

From ethics complaints involving Supreme Court justices to a Florida judge targeting an Illinois attorney over critical comments, the legal landscape continues to be fraught with ethical dilemmas and legal battles that underscore the complexities of maintaining judicial and professional integrity.

Looking Ahead: Ethics in Law

As we move forward, these cases present an ongoing challenge to the legal community’s commitment to upholding the highest standards of conduct. They also serve as a critical reminder of the intricate balance required between legal authority and ethical responsibility in the pursuit of justice and professional integrity.

Each of these stories not only shapes the legal landscape but also influences public trust in our legal systems. As we continue to navigate these challenging waters, the lessons learned will undoubtedly contribute to the evolving standards of legal ethics and professional conduct in the increasingly complex modern world.