September 12, 2025

In this week’s edition of “How Appealing Weekly Roundup,” we delve into a series of compelling legal narratives that highlight pivotal moments in U.S. appellate litigation. From Supreme Court discussions to cross-state legal battles, the landscape of American law continues to evolve, bringing with it a mixture of controversy and critical legal reform.
Justice Amy Coney Barrett Speaks at Nixon Library
The Richard Nixon Foundation recently offered the public a rare glimpse into the judicial perspective of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett. A video posted on YouTube captures Justice Barrett’s presentation, shedding light on her viewpoints and judicial philosophy. This appearance underscores her influence in the ongoing dialogues within America's highest court.
Supreme Court Decision Sparks Criticism Over Racial Considerations in Immigration
A significant ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court has ignited a firestorm of criticism from various sectors. The court’s decision to allow immigration enforcement that factors in race and ethnicity has been reported by David G. Savage, Michael Wilner, and Andrea Castillo of The Los Angeles Times. Critics argue that this ruling may pave the way for discriminatory practices under the guise of law enforcement.
Florida Parents Escalate Gender Pronoun Dispute to Supreme Court
In Florida, a heated legal struggle concerning gender identity and parental rights has reached the U.S. Supreme Court. January and Jeffrey Littlejohn argue that Leon Schools implemented a ‘gender-support plan’ for their child without their consent, reports Stephany Matat of The Tallahassee Democrat. This case could have profound implications on how schools across the nation handle sensitive issues related to gender identity.
Los Angeles Immigrants Brace for ICE Raids
Following another controversial Supreme Court ruling that lifts restrictions on immigration raids, fear is mounting among immigrant communities in Los Angeles. Reporting for The Los Angeles Times, Brittny Mejia, Rachel Uranga, and Ruben Vives highlight the tense atmosphere as many anticipate increased ICE activities. The decision has been met with dread and apprehension, reflecting broader national anxieties over immigration policies.
Revelations in Trump Administration’s Deal with El Salvador
A $4.7 million contract between the Trump administration and El Salvador intended for prison construction has surfaced through a federal court disclosure. Nick Penzenstadler and Eduardo Cuevas of USA Today report on this development, which emerged amidst a lawsuit by human rights organizations challenging the ethical implications of the contract.
New York vs. Texas: A Legal Showdown Over Abortion Pills
The ongoing legal confrontation between New York and Texas takes center stage as New York Attorney General Letitia James prepares to challenge a Texas law that threatens access to abortion pills. Praveena Somasundaram of The Washington Post reports on this clash between state legal powers, encapsulating a broader national debate over reproductive rights.
Each of these stories not only reflects individual legal battles but also illustrates the broader, dynamic challenges facing the American legal system today. For more comprehensive coverage and detailed discussions, visit Howard Bashman’s “How Appealing” blog.