September 23, 2025

The integration of agentic artificial intelligence (AI) into healthcare is poised to revolutionize medical diagnostics and treatment but may also usher in a host of legal complexities, warns a leading attorney specializing in healthcare law. As AI systems increasingly perform tasks independently, the ambiguity around liability and accountability in medical outcomes becomes a pressing concern.
Agentic AI, characterized by its capacity to make autonomous decisions, is being rapidly adopted across various sectors of healthcare. This includes diagnosing patients, prescribing treatments, and in some cases, performing surgical procedures with minimal human oversight. While these advancements could significantly enhance efficiency and patient care, they also raise substantial legal questions, particularly regarding malpractice and patient rights.
The primary legal challenge lies in determining who is held accountable when an AI system makes a faulty decision that results in patient harm. Traditional healthcare law assigns liability based on human error, but the autonomous nature of agentic AI complicates this framework. If an AI system, for example, misdiagnoses a condition leading to incorrect treatment, the question arises: is the liability to be borne by the software developer, the medical facility, or the AI itself?
Further complicating the issue is the current lack of comprehensive regulation specific to AI in healthcare. Existing laws do not fully cover the scope of autonomous AI operations, leading to potential gaps in accountability. This legal gray area not only poses risks to patient safety but also to the providers who might hesitate to adopt potentially beneficial AI technology due to uncertainty about legal repercussions.
The attorney emphasizes the urgent need for policymakers to develop clear guidelines and regulations that address these new challenges. Such regulations should define the scope of AI autonomy in healthcare, establish standards for AI system testing and monitoring, and create a framework for liability that considers the unique aspects of AI operation.
As AI continues to evolve, the legal system must adapt to ensure that the benefits of agentic AI in healthcare can be realized without compromising patient safety or provider accountability. This will require a collaborative effort among legal experts, technologists, and policymakers to forge a path that respects the nuances of emerging AI technologies while upholding the highest standards of care and justice in healthcare.