October 14, 2025


Former Justice Anthony Kennedy Expresses Worry Over Supreme Court's Increasingly Personal Tone

In a candid interview with CBS News, former Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy voiced his concerns about the current state of the Supreme Court, describing it as "too personal and confrontational." The remarks came as Kennedy discussed themes from his new memoir, "Life, Law and Liberty."

Kennedy, who has often been pivotal in major court decisions during his tenure, expressed unease over the tone and approach of recent judicial opinions. Without naming specific colleagues or cases, he highlighted a shift away from the court’s traditionally stoic and measured discourse toward what he perceives as a more divisive and personal tone. "It’s a little bit too personal and confrontational, some of the opinions," Kennedy stated, expressing hope for a return to less heated rhetoric.

The former justice elaborated on the essential qualities of democracy, emphasizing the need for "an open, rational, thoughtful, decent discussion where you respect the dignity of the person with whom you disagree." Kennedy warned that the absence of such respect and civility could pose a threat to the very fabric of American democracy.

Kennedy's comments come at a time when the Supreme Court has been under intense scrutiny, with recent rulings sparking widespread debate and, in some instances, public outcry. His insights offer a rare glimpse into the internal perspectives of those who have shaped the nation's highest court, and they serve as a reminder of the ongoing challenges facing the judicial system in maintaining decorum and respect in its proceedings.

As society grapples with polarized political climates and contentious legal battles, Kennedy’s reflections underscore the critical need for a judiciary that not only decides but also deliberates with civility and respect for differing viewpoints.