October 24, 2025

In a dramatic turn of events, New York Attorney General Letitia James faced arraignment this morning in Norfolk on charges of mortgage fraud. The case, prosecuted by US Attorney Lindsey Halligan, took an unexpected twist as Signal messages between Halligan and a media editor surfaced, casting shadows on the legal proceedings.
The messages, which were directed at Lawfare editor Anna Bower concerning her publication of a potentially case-damaging story, have now become part of a legal motion. James's defense, led by the renowned Abbe Lowell and local counsel Andrew Bosse, filed a "Motion to Enforce Rules Prohibiting the Government's Extrajudicial Disclosures." This motion highlighted the severity of the leak, citing multiple violations including potential breaches of federal records laws due to the auto-deleting nature of Signal messages.
The courtroom drama escalated when James's legal team requested that the court enforce strict guidelines on preserving communications and maintaining a log of all prosecutor-media interactions related to the case. Furthermore, they signaled an intent to challenge Halligan’s appointment as interim U.S. Attorney, questioning its legality and suggesting a consolidation of similar motions for efficiency.
Adding to the complexity, Halligan's efforts to manage the case have been fraught with difficulties. She had to recruit Roger A. Keller, an Assistant U.S. Attorney from Missouri, to join the prosecution team after local attorneys distanced themselves from the case. This development followed a report by ABC News which seemed to undermine the prosecution's claims about James's financial dealings with her great-niece.
As the case prepares to move forward with a trial date set for January 26, the legal landscape is rife with challenges. The initial appearance in court has already laid the groundwork for what promises to be a contentious and closely watched legal battle, with serious implications for all parties involved.