November 4, 2025

In a surprising turn of events that underscores the importance of integrity in the judiciary, a western New York judge has stepped down from his position amid allegations of misusing his office to avoid penalties for traffic violations. The former Clarkson Town Court Justice, Ian Penders, who has been an attorney since 2014, resigned during an ongoing investigation by the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct (CJC).
The inquiry into Penders' conduct began after it was discovered that he had been stopped by police officers on two separate occasions in June for driving without a valid license. In an effort to circumvent the law, Penders reportedly attempted to invoke his judicial status to escape receiving tickets. This led to further scrutiny and eventually, on August 15, he pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of aggravated unlicensed operation of a motor vehicle in the third degree.
The situation sheds light on the challenges and temptations faced by public officials, particularly in less urban areas of New York where public transportation options are limited. While New York City residents might have the luxury of opting for a train or bus, those in more rural settings like Monroe County, where Penders served, often rely heavily on personal vehicles for transportation.
This case adds to a growing list of incidents involving judges who step outside the bounds of ethical behavior, highlighting the critical need for constant professionalism and adherence to the law, regardless of one's position. Although relatively mild compared to other judicial misconduct cases, the incident with Judge Penders underscores the low tolerance for any appearance of impropriety in the judiciary.
The CJC's ongoing commitment to maintaining ethical standards within New York's judicial system is evident in their handling of this case. As public servants, the expectation is that judges not only enforce the law but abide by it, setting an example for the community at large.
The full details of the investigation and subsequent resignation can be found on Law.com, which provides comprehensive coverage of legal news and developments. As the judicial system continues to evolve and adapt, maintaining integrity and public trust remains a top priority, ensuring that those who wield the gavel are also willing to stand accountable before it.