Halloween is a season known not just for spooky celebrations but also for some controversial costume choices that often lead to professional repercussions. This year, a Missouri judge found himself in a tight spot, not for a distasteful costume but for his overzealous celebration of Elvis Presley. Judge Matthew Thornhill, a St. Charles County judge, is set to retire following disciplinary actions over his Halloween antics which included dressing as Elvis in court.

The controversy began when Judge Thornhill swapped his judicial robes for an Elvis jumpsuit on Halloween. His transformation didn't stop at attire; his courtroom resonated with Elvis tunes and references throughout the proceedings. This unusual mix of pop culture and judicial duties did not sit well with the authorities, leading to a six-month unpaid suspension as per the agreement with the Missouri Supreme Court’s Commission on Retirement, Removal, and Discipline.

Following his suspension, Thornhill is allowed a brief return to the bench for an 18-month stint, after which he has agreed to retire and not seek reelection. This arrangement enables him to retire with full benefits, marking 20 years of service. Photos and videos of his Elvis impersonation, which can be seen [here](https://www.youtube.com/embed/FPGxs0is3aQ?feature=oembed), showcase the judge's commitment to his Halloween costume, which unfortunately coincided with a regular court day.

The incident raises questions about the appropriateness of such behavior in a professional setting, especially on a day like Halloween, which this year fell on a Friday, colloquially known as 'casual Friday' in many workplaces. This situation mirrors a recent decision by a New York judge who allowed lawyers the option to wear costumes to a Friday hearing, suggesting that perhaps advance notice might have spared Judge Thornhill his current predicament.

However, it's crucial to note that dressing up as Elvis isn't the sole reason behind the disciplinary action. The judge also faced accusations of discussing his political affiliations openly and inappropriately handling official documents related to an adoption case. These actions, combined with his Halloween celebration, painted a broader picture of misconduct.

While the Elvis incident adds a lighter note to the story, it underscores the ongoing debate about the boundaries of professional conduct and personal expression. As Judge Thornhill prepares for his suspension and subsequent retirement, the legal community and the public are left to ponder the limits of thematic holiday celebrations within the solemn walls of the judiciary.