January 6, 2026


Judge Hannah Dugan Steps Down Following Felony Obstruction Conviction

In a stunning turn of events that underscores the tumultuous political and judicial landscape, Milwaukee County Judge Hannah Dugan has resigned from her position. This decision came immediately after her conviction on charges of obstructing federal agents, marking a significant career downfall amidst the broader context of an increasingly authoritarian administration.

The conviction and subsequent resignation were announced through a tweet by journalist Matt Smith, who shared Dugan's resignation letter. This development effectively halts any ongoing efforts to impeach her, clearing the path for a gubernatorial appointment to fill her now-vacant seat. Observers note that the new appointee will have considerable shoes to fill, given Dugan’s previously strong stance on justice issues.

Judge Dugan's legal troubles stem from a broader crackdown on judicial independence, highlighted by several unsettling instances where judges faced federal repercussions for opposing executive policies. Under the current administration, which saw Donald Trump re-elected, the federal government has taken aggressive steps against those it views as oppositional. This includes leveraging executive orders against private industries, detaining student journalists, and threatening protesters with deportation.

Particularly contentious was the administration's policy to use ICE in courthouses, a move Dugan opposed. Historically, courthouses were exempt from ICE patrols to prevent interference with access to justice. People seeking restraining orders or addressing grievances against landlords were assured safety from immigration enforcement, a policy upended during Trump's second term.

The broader implications of Dugan’s obstruction conviction and resignation are profound. They reflect the ongoing challenges and fears faced by the judiciary under an administration willing to push legal boundaries. For many legal professionals and civil rights advocates, these developments signal an alarming shift towards less judicial independence and increased government overreach.

As the legal community and observers await the appointment of a new judge, the conversation continues about the balance of power and the protection of judicial independence in an era where these values are being aggressively questioned. The hope expressed in Judge Dugan's resignation letter points to a lingering faith in the judicial process, but whether this hope is well-placed remains to be seen.