February 27, 2026


Exploring the Deep Flaws in the Justice System Through the Eyes of a Public Defender

In a revealing discussion on The Jabot Podcast, Emily Galvin Almanza, a seasoned public defender and reform advocate, delves into the intricate and often heartbreaking realities of the U.S. criminal justice system as outlined in her latest book, "The Price of Mercy." Emily's journey into the realm of law was as unexpected as it was eye-opening, driven by a profound commitment to defend those ensnared by a system that seemingly punishes instability more frequently than actual criminal acts.

Emily's narrative is not just about the legal battles in the courts but also about the emotional and societal toll on those involved. Her experiences highlight how policy decisions, rather than moral failings, often dictate who gets entangled in the justice system. This critical viewpoint sheds light on the broader implications of incarceration, emphasizing that the consequences extend beyond the individual to touch on broader economic and social issues.

The discussion also touches on the personal toll such work takes on public defenders themselves, who face high rates of burnout in their relentless pursuit of justice. Emily's insights into the system's misconceptions are potent, especially her critique of how the legal framework is often more about managing social instabilities rather than administering justice in its truest sense.

Moreover, Emily and the podcast host explore the role of compassion in reforming policies and the fundamental rethinking of justice not as a means of punishment but as a crucial pillar of public safety and community stability. The aim is to transform justice into a system that upholds human dignity and fosters a more stable society.

The conversation is a crucial one, as it reframes the narrative around criminal justice from one of mere legal procedure to a more humane and holistic view of what it means to serve the public and protect the vulnerable. It is a call to action for all stakeholders in the justice system to seek reformative measures that prioritize human dignity and social welfare over punitive approaches.

This podcast not only illuminates the challenges faced by those on the front lines of criminal defense but also serves as a poignant reminder of the human costs associated with a flawed justice system. Emily Galvin Almanza's passionate advocacy and firsthand experiences provide a compelling case for urgent reforms aimed at healing and stabilizing communities across the nation.