In the latest edition of the How Appealing Weekly Roundup, we dive into some of the most pivotal legal battles and discussions shaping the appellate courts. From high-profile defamation cases to critical decisions on presidential powers and gun control, here’s a snapshot of the week’s significant legal events.

Trump Entangled in Legal Reversals at Sullivan & Cromwell

In a startling turn of events, the prestigious law firm Sullivan & Cromwell has decided to represent Donald Trump in his appeal against sex-abuse and defamation claims made by E. Jean Carroll. This decision came after the firm’s co-chairman initially assured partners of their non-involvement. The reversal, prompted by a request from Trump’s personal lawyer, has sparked internal division within the firm. The Wall Street Journal’s detailed report sheds light on the intricate dynamics at play.

Constitutional Green Light for Illinois AR-15 Ban

The Seventh Circuit has upheld Illinois' ban on AR-15s, declaring it constitutional. This decision marks a significant moment in the ongoing debate over gun control in the United States. While full details require Bloomberg Law subscription, the ruling is a critical development in the interpretation of Second Amendment rights.

Supreme Court’s Grip on Presidential Power

An in-depth essay from Balls and Strikes critiques the Supreme Court's recent decision which not only shifts political power from Congress to the executive branch but also significantly increases the judicial branch's hold over political decisions. This analysis by Madiba K. Dennie provides a compelling look at how the conservative justices are shaping the landscape of presidential authority.

Farewell to the Supreme Court’s Last Official Crier

The Supreme Court has bid farewell to its last official crier, George Hutchinson, who passed away at the age of 102. Starting as a court page at just 15, Hutchinson’s lifetime of service culminated in his role as the announcer of the justices' arrival and the one to bring the court to order. The Washington Post’s obituary offers a poignant glimpse into his distinguished career.

Judicial Conduct Complaint Transferred Amidst Scrutiny

In another significant judicial development, Chief Justice John G. Roberts, Jr. has transferred a conduct and disability complaint against Circuit Judge Ryan D. Nelson to the Judicial Council of the Fourth Circuit. This move, as reported by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, underscores the ongoing scrutiny and procedural adherence within the highest levels of the judiciary.

Insights from SCOTUSblog’s Executive Editor on Supreme Court’s Recent Term

Zach Shemtob, the executive editor of SCOTUSblog, shared his insights on the major rulings and themes from the October Term 2025 on David Lat’s “Original Jurisdiction” podcast. This discussion is crucial for anyone interested in understanding the directional shifts and focal points of the Supreme Court during the term.

For more detailed analyses and a broader spectrum of appellate litigation stories, visit Howard Bashman’s How Appealing blog. Stay informed with these legal developments that not only influence the judicial landscape but also impact broader societal norms.