November 19, 2026

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill is refusing a federal judge’s directive to apologize for accusing Southeastern Conference lawyers of using “hallucinated” legal citations, escalating a dispute that began with LSU’s effort to add former professional athletes to its football team.
U.S. District Judge Annemarie Carney Axon warned LSU’s lawyers on Wednesday that they could face severe sanctions after the state suggested in an October 20 court filing that key SEC citations “appear to be negligently supplied or hallucinated.” The cited cases, however, were real.
The SEC sued LSU in federal court in Alabama in September after coach Lane Kiffin sought to sign former NFL players with the support of a Louisiana state-court order. LSU backed away from that plan, but the litigation continued as the school sought to add a former professional basketball player.
At Wednesday’s hearing, LSU’s local counsel, Bruce Rogers, acknowledged that the disputed cases existed. “They’re not made-up cases,” he said, while arguing that “hallucinated” could have a broader meaning.
Axon rejected that explanation and questioned whether attacks on opposing lawyers’ professional reputations constituted legitimate advocacy. “You put the pig out there,” she told Rogers. “There’s no time for you to put lipstick on it.”
The judge directed Rogers to move to strike the term and acknowledge that its use reflected “poor professional judgment.” She also sought “robust, heartfelt” statements of regret from Rogers, LSU and the attorney general’s office, warning that another such incident could bring sanctions “to the fullest extent I can.”
Murrill said she “cannot and will not apologize for my lawyers doing their job,” arguing that an Alabama federal judge should not compel Louisiana to speak. In a letter to the court, her office asserted that the compelled-speech doctrine protected the state from being required to publish a particular message. The letter also defended the original criticism, citing the SEC’s acknowledged use of artificial intelligence in its workflow.
Murrill did approve striking the “hallucination” language. Whether that step will satisfy the court remains to be seen; Axon’s warning concerned potential future sanctions, not a penalty already imposed.
The dispute has also drawn in Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry, who criticized Axon on social media as a University of Alabama alumna. Attorney Tom Mars, a Kiffin confidant, warned that a judge has sanctions available even if a party contests an apology directive.
Meanwhile, Georgia Attorney General Chris Carr urged SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey to consider conference sanctions against LSU, “up to and including expulsion,” over the school’s effort to add the former basketball professional. That request is separate from the federal judge’s warning but underscores the widening stakes for LSU.