November 19, 2026


DOJ Recruitment of New Law Graduates Raises Concerns About Prosecutor Experience

The Justice Department’s recruitment of lawyers directly from law school is drawing criticism from former federal prosecutors, who say the departure from longstanding hiring practices could weaken the government’s ability to handle complex criminal cases.

Before President Donald Trump’s second term, the department typically required new federal prosecutors to have three to five years of legal experience. A [ProPublica investigation](https://www.propublica.org/article/federal-prosecutors-hiring-trump-doj/) identified more than 50 newly hired assistant U.S. attorneys with less than three years of experience.

Juliet Sorensen, a Loyola University Chicago law professor and former assistant U.S. attorney, described the department’s active recruitment of recent law graduates as “an astounding break with past practice.”

“It reflects a lowering of standards for a job that is important and requires lawyers who are meticulous, committed to doing the right thing, and bring with them experience beyond just law school,” Sorensen said.

The distinction matters because assistant U.S. attorneys represent the federal government in cases that can carry serious consequences for defendants, victims and the public. Sorensen’s concern is not simply that new graduates are entering government service, but that they are being recruited for prosecutorial jobs that have traditionally called for substantial legal experience.

The ProPublica finding captures a broader group than lawyers hired immediately after graduation: the investigation identified more than 50 new assistant U.S. attorneys with fewer than three years of experience, without suggesting that all were hired straight from law school.

Former U.S. Attorney Barbara McQuade also warned of consequences if federal offices lack experienced prosecutors. “Some very serious crimes will go unpunished,” she said.

Together, the warnings raise questions about how federal prosecutors are being prepared for their responsibilities as the department changes its hiring approach. The concerns center on both the judgment required to pursue cases and the ability to bring them effectively.

The shift marks a contrast with the experience requirements that generally prevailed before Trump’s second term. For critics such as Sorensen, recruiting directly from law school removes a period in which lawyers could develop skills before taking on the demands of federal prosecution.