November 20, 2026


Appellate Roundup: Public Defense, Press Freedom and Election Disputes in Focus

The promise of legal representation, the limits of press protections and a dispute over an Alaska election are among the issues drawing attention across the legal landscape this week, according to items highlighted by Howard Bashman’s How Appealing blog.

In an essay for The Washington Post, Chesa Boudin and University of California, Berkeley law professor Erwin Chemerinsky argue that overworked public defenders’ offices are undermining the constitutional right to an attorney. They contend that the Sixth Amendment’s promise depends on whether public defenders have enough time and resources to represent their clients.

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court is set to hear Lindsay Clancy’s petition to dismiss murder charges arising from the deaths of her children, Shelley Murphy and John R. Ellement report for The Boston Globe. The petition puts the charges before the state’s highest court.

In election litigation, the Trump administration’s Justice Department has given up its effort in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit to block certification of Mary Peltola’s victory in Alaska’s U.S. Senate election, according to a post by Rick Hasen on Election Law Blog.

A look back at press freedom comes from Adam Liptak’s “The Docket” newsletter at The New York Times. Liptak examines the history of a 1972 case involving protections for confidential sources, including an FBI campaign against the Black Panthers and a justice’s questionable decision not to recuse himself. The case dealt a blow to those protections.

Judicial nominations also drew attention in Texas, where Sen. John Cornyn blocked a top Justice Department official nominated for a judicial vacancy, The Associated Press’s Seung Min Kim reports.

Meanwhile, prediction market company Kalshi suffered another setback in Maryland litigation, according to Joe Dodson of Courthouse News Service. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit rejected the company’s argument that federal law preempts the state from requiring it to comply with state laws on matters including deceptive advertising.

The selection spans criminal defense, elections, judicial appointments and regulation, illustrating the range of appellate and legal issues tracked by How Appealing, which is devoted to appellate litigation.