November 20, 2026


The Failure to Protect America’s Soldiers

Military service comes with risks, but a Berkeley law professor argues that accepting those risks should not mean surrendering protection from unnecessary harm—or losing access to legal remedies when the government fails to provide it.

Saira Mohamed, the Agnes Roddy Robb Chair in Jurisprudence, Ethics, and Social Responsibility at the University of California, Berkeley, makes that case in her book, *What a Country Owes Its Soldiers*. In an episode of *The Jabot* podcast, she discussed the obligations governments owe service members and the legal and cultural barriers to fulfilling them.

Mohamed argues that a government owes soldiers the same fundamental duties it owes other people under its authority and control. Those duties, she says, include protecting them from unnecessary dangers and illegal orders.

Her argument does not deny that military service is inherently dangerous. Rather, it draws a distinction between risks that are unavoidable and those that need not be imposed. The existence of the former, in Mohamed’s view, does not excuse the government from trying to prevent the latter.

That distinction also bears on the remedies available to service members and their families. The podcast discussion addressed the Feres Doctrine, which, read broadly, bars service members and their survivors from suing for injuries sustained in service. Mohamed calls it a strange rule, questioning a legal framework that can leave people injured in military service without an avenue to sue.

Mohamed also challenges the idea that volunteering for military service resolves questions about government responsibility. The argument that service members “signed up for it,” she says, overlooks the limits on their ability to leave: unlike people in many civilian jobs, they cannot simply quit and can face prosecution for leaving.

The discussion also considered exploitation and military readiness, placing the treatment of service members within a broader debate over what a country can ask of those who serve.

For Mohamed, legal changes alone are not the starting point. She sees cultural change as a necessary precursor: soldiers must be understood as people, rather than instruments.

That shift would place their welfare at the center of questions about military obligations, including how much risk service members should bear and what recourse they should have when avoidable harm occurs.