November 20, 2026

A Kentucky detective could not rely solely on a facial recognition match to establish probable cause for an arrest, a court has ruled, allowing a lawsuit to proceed over the wrongful identification of a Nebraska man.
The case arose from an investigation into an allegedly bad check passed at a bank. Detective Ryan Kilmer of the Florence Police Department used a screenshot from the bank’s surveillance footage to search a facial recognition system, which returned a match to a Facebook profile.
According to the court, Kilmer accepted the identification without corroboration. The Facebook profile was associated with a person identified as “Yony Smith Npoles Charon,” but the court said it was unclear why the detective concluded that the profile depicted Alain Vizcay Osorio.
Osorio, who lived in Nebraska, was arrested and extradited to Kentucky. He was released on bond on January 24, 2025, indicted by a grand jury in March and arraigned roughly two months later. Prosecutors dismissed the charges after Osorio, who had pleaded not guilty, provided evidence that he was working in Nebraska when the check was passed.
The court found significant differences between Osorio’s booking photograph and the images of the suspected check passer. It said the only apparent similarities were that both were Black men with facial hair. Osorio appeared to have a different head shape, haircut, facial features and complexion, the court wrote.
Kilmer said in an affidavit that he had used “investigative tools” to match Osorio to the suspect. The court said he had relied on a single tool, despite a Florence Police Department policy stating that facial recognition alone cannot establish probable cause.
“The Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution does not allow a detective to delegate to AI the task of assessing probable cause,” the court wrote. It added that an individual cannot be arrested based on “nothing more than an uncorroborated conclusion by AI” that the person committed a crime.
The court also rejected Kilmer’s claim to qualified immunity, finding that no reasonable detective in his position could have concluded otherwise. Qualified immunity can shield government officials from liability for conduct that does not violate clearly established rights.
The decision does not identify the facial recognition product used in the investigation. Its immediate focus is the uncorroborated match in Osorio’s case, rather than a blanket ban on police use of AI. The ruling nevertheless adds to the legal scrutiny of automated tools as law enforcement agencies increasingly use them in investigations and other police work.