November 20, 2026

A federal judge in Chicago has rejected a Justice Department request to assign a special master to resolve privilege disputes in an inquiry into prosecutors’ conduct in the case of the “Broadview Six,” faulting the government for waiting until the eve of a deadline to raise the issue.
U.S. District Judge April Perry said deciding questions of privilege is a judicial function and that judges routinely assess evidence in proceedings where they also serve as fact-finders. She also called the department’s request untimely, noting that prosecutors had known for months that the inquiry could involve privileged communications.
“The Government waited until 6:50 p.m. the night before potentially privileged materials would be tendered to the Court to file its motion,” Perry wrote in a [minute order](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/71795964/323/united-states-v-rabbitt/).
The dispute stems from the government’s now-dismissed obstruction case against six people charged following a protest involving an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent’s vehicle. Prosecutors had previously dismissed allegations of misconduct as “fevered paranoia and delusional speculation,” but subsequently unsealed grand jury transcripts revealed problems in three presentations to the same grand jury in October 2025.
U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros told Perry in open court that he discovered the problem five months later. But Perry noted that Boutros had been emailed the first grand jury transcript five days after the presentation. She also questioned how he could have approved presenting the case again after a grand jury declined to indict without examining the transcript.
The government initially told the court that its Chicago office had not discussed the case with Justice Department headquarters. In August, it acknowledged discussions involving case updates. Separately, the former head of the FBI’s Chicago office alleged in a lawsuit that Boutros met with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche and FBI Director Kash Patel about the case.
Associate Attorney General Stan Woodward entered the matter on October 30, shortly before a court deadline. In a later [filing](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/71795964/322/united-states-v-rabbitt/), he argued that because Perry had assumed what he described as an executive-branch role, an independent judicial officer should decide privilege questions arising from her inquiry.
Perry disagreed, citing decisions recognizing privilege determinations as a judicial responsibility and the presumption that judges can disregard improper evidence. She also noted that a special master’s rulings would remain subject to her review.
The prosecutors involved were due to submit private summaries of their expected testimony to Perry, including material the department considers privileged. The Justice Department has until Tuesday to explain why she should not review them. The parties are scheduled to return to court on December 2.